A CFO at a company under $50M in revenue told us his collections were 95% automated through Stripe. We had opened with our payments pitch, and that was the end of it.
We think that ending was the mistake. “We’re already automated” is not a rejection of the product. It’s a claim about a system, and every system has a remainder: the payments that fail, the reconciliations that don’t match, the exceptions someone clears by hand every week.
So we now qualify before we pitch. Before we mention payments, we need to know how many failed payments the team sees in a month and how many recover without a person, how long month-end reconciliation takes and who runs it, and what happens to an exception after it’s flagged. If nobody can answer, or the honest answer is “nobody touches it,” we stop. That’s a correct outcome, not a lost call.
When the prospect says they’re already automated, we don’t defend the automation. We ask about the remainder: “Of the payments that come in each month, how many still need a person to look at them?” At $50M in collections, 5% is $2.5M a year moving through a manual step. That number matters to a CFO far more than any claim about our product.
This week we ran five qualifying calls in our outbound. They lasted between 462 and 672 seconds. Four of the five contacts were marked decision makers, and two meetings were booked. The two that booked both started from how the contact actually does the work, not from what we sell.
One call showed the pattern clearly. A director of executive protection told us his patrol app’s vendor had no open API. He wasn’t going to replace a whole system because of the learning curve and timing, but the integration question was the real issue. We sent information by email and kept the conversation on that question. A managing partner overseeing about 30 LLCs, mostly filing annual reports in Michigan, asked how we handle registered agent work. That turned into a side-by-side comparison, booked for December 9.
The longest call of the five, 672 seconds, ended with no follow-up. The CEO liked a pay-per-meeting model, but that model typically requires $5M+ in funding, and the company was likely too small for it. The call ran eleven minutes before we confirmed that. Check funding and fit first, before the demo.
The same logic applies to payments. A CFO who says “we’re automated” has given you useful information: the easy part is done. Your job is to find the part that isn’t, and let them tell you what it costs.