Most reps have run into this. A prospect who closed months ago, or who went quiet after a good call, stops answering the questions that matter. You ask what changed, whether the budget moved, or what’s working, and you get “all good” or nothing at all.
The instinct is to ask again, more politely. That usually fails. A better move is to say something slightly wrong on purpose.
Here’s how it works. Instead of asking an open question, you state an assumption that’s a little off and let the prospect correct you. People rarely let a wrong fact stand when they can fix it. Correcting you is easier than volunteering information, and it feels like helping.
These three examples are illustrative, but they show the shape:
A customer signed a 12-month contract last spring and you haven’t heard from them since. Instead of “How’s everything going with the platform?” try: “I’m guessing you’re still on the smaller plan and haven’t needed to expand yet?” If they’ve upgraded, they’ll say so. Now you know they grew, who owns the decision, and what they’re using it for. Being wrong about the plan got them talking.
A prospect went dark after a pricing conversation. Instead of “Did you make a decision?” try: “I assume you went with someone cheaper, or you’re holding off until next year?” People tend to correct the second half. “We didn’t go with anyone. We’re waiting on budget approval in Q1.” That’s a real timeline you can plan around, and they gave it to you.
You’re not sure your contact still works there. Try: “I’m assuming you’re still the person running this, so I’ll send the update to you?” If they say they moved teams and someone else handles it now, you have a new name and a reason to reach out.
Three rules keep this from backfiring.
First, make the assumption plausible. An absurd guess gets dismissed. A reasonable one gets corrected. Base it on what you actually know from the account history.
Second, keep it low stakes. Don’t guess something that would embarrass them or touch a sensitive topic, like layoffs or a competitor they dropped.
Third, be ready for a confirmation. If you guessed right, that’s useful too. Acknowledge it and move on. Don’t keep pushing the same point.
This matters in practice. This month we’re on track for 19 qualified meetings, up from 17 last month, and about half of bookings are coming from nurture lists. These are people who already know us and have gone quiet or said no before. Reps working those lists don’t get better results by sending more follow-ups. They get better results when each message gives the prospect something easy to respond to. A wrong assumption is one of the easiest things to respond to, because it asks for a correction rather than a confession.
I think it works because it removes the pressure of a question. Nobody has to decide what to share. They just have to say, “No, actually…” That’s a much smaller ask.
Here’s a starting point. Pull five closed or stalled accounts this week. Write one assumption for each, based on what you know, and send it. Track how many replies contain a fact you didn’t have before. You’ll quickly learn which assumptions are plausible enough to draw a correction and which are too far off to land.
Stonewalls are usually about the question, not the relationship. Change the question, and the conversation often starts again.