Most prospects will give you a cost number that’s too low. They’re not lying. Nobody has ever added it up for them.
On a recent discovery call, a prospect put their annual spend on this at around $10k. It sounded plausible, the kind of number you hear, nod at, and move past.
I didn’t correct them. I asked how many entities the process ran across. The answer was about 100. Then I asked what they paid per entity today. Roughly $400 each, across 100 entities, comes to about $40k a year. Their guess was off by a factor of four.
That gap is the whole lesson.
Why letting them find it works better than telling them
If I had said, “Actually, it’s closer to $40k,” the prospect would have had two weak options: argue with me or accept my number. Arguing wastes time. Accepting a vendor’s figure feels like being sold to.
When they do the multiplication themselves, the number belongs to them. It stops being a vague cost in the background and becomes a concrete figure they produced. They can’t unsee it.
It also shifts the question from “is this worth it?” to “what are we doing about this?” A $10k line item is easy to defer. A $40k annual cost that the buyer found on their own is a different conversation.
How to run it
Keep it simple.
Ask for inputs, not the total. “How many entities does this touch?” and “What does each one cost you today, roughly?” are easier to answer than “What do you spend a year?”
Let them do the arithmetic. Don’t multiply for them. After they give you the second number, stop talking and let them work it out.
Ask what the gap means. “So if it’s closer to $40k, what does that say about the $10k estimate?” Let them answer it.
Turn the gap into a timeline. At $40k a year, that’s roughly $3,300 a month. Ask what it costs them to wait another quarter on the current setup.
The last step is where urgency comes from. You aren’t inventing a deadline or applying pressure. You’re asking the prospect to price the delay using their own numbers.
Be careful with the number
Don’t present a gap as savings until you’ve shown how the savings happen. If a prospect finds a $30k difference and then feels managed, they’ll stop trusting everything you say next. Every figure should trace back to something they told you.
Also, don’t use this to catch people out. If their number is too low, the goal is to help them see it, not to win the point.
What I’d take from it
The cheapest sales tool I have is a calculator in the prospect’s hands. Vague costs get ignored. Concrete ones get acted on. Next time a prospect gives you a round number, ask how many units sit behind it, and let them finish the sum.